43% of Podcast Consumers Have Taken a Community Action. How to Turn Listeners Into an Actual Community

New research suggests podcast fans are already reaching out to each other. Here is the difference between an audience and a community, and how to start small without launching a ghost town.

Jessica Tamar Young
Jessica Tamar Young
Head of Content Marketing, Poddster
·
November 20, 2026
·
3
min read
The Power of Community research graphic from Locked On, Sounds Profitable and Coleman Insights, with a callout saying 43% have taken a podcast-related community action
Key takeaways
  • New research among 2,000 Americans found 43% of podcast consumers have taken a community action, from chatting with other listeners to attending a live show.
  • Roughly half say podcasts keep them company when they don't have people around.
  • An audience is one-to-many. A community also connects members with each other, so it needs a different plan.
  • Start with a small group and personal invitations, then choose a platform once you know what people need.

"You should build a community" may be the most common advice in podcasting, and one of the least helpful. Plenty of shows have opened a Discord or Facebook group, posted three times, and watched it go quiet.

The appetite seems real, though. New research from Sounds Profitable, Coleman Insights and Locked On Podcast Network, among 2,000 Americans, found that 43% of podcast consumers have taken a podcast-related community action, from chatting with other listeners to attending a live show. Roughly half say podcasts keep them company when they don't have people around.

So people want connection. The hard part is giving them somewhere worth showing up.

Audience and community aren't the same thing

An audience listens to you. A community also talks to each other.

You probably already know the first half. Hosts build real bonds, and that's why the host is often the reason people keep listening. But a fan's connection with a host doesn't automatically make them want to meet other fans. That takes a shared reason to be there.

In a recent Captivate write-up on this subject, consultant Seth Resler describes audience and community as "two different business models". That's a helpful way to look at it. A community costs time every week. Before you start one, decide what it's for.

Read more: Listeners don't think podcasters are influencers. But most say one has changed their mind.

How to start without building a ghost town

1. Start with a small group

Don't announce a community to everyone. Pick 10 to 20 listeners you already know: people who reply to your emails, leave comments or turn up at events. A small, active group looks far better to a newcomer than 500 silent members.

2. Ask before you build

Have a real conversation about what they want. Do they want to swap advice, meet in person or get closer to the show? The answers will shape everything after this.

3. Build it with them

Resler's advice is worth keeping: "Don't go build a community space for your members. What you really need to do is build a space with your members." Give your first members roles and let them shape the rules.

4. Invite people one by one

An announcement goes out to everyone and asks nothing of anyone in particular. A personal note says you thought of them. That doesn't scale, and in the early days it shouldn't.

5. Choose a focus and protect it

Narrow communities are easier to join and easier to run. Steve Stewart's Podcast Editors Club, for example, keeps its discussion tightly on podcast editing. Decide what's on topic, then enforce it kindly.

6. Pick the platform last

Discord, Slack, Circle, Mighty Networks and Facebook all work for someone. Pick the one your first members already use or are happy to use. A clever platform nobody opens won't help.

Don't forget the offline side

Community doesn't have to mean a forum. An email list that invites replies counts as a start, which is one more reason your podcast needs a companion newsletter. So does a meetup. Live events are a strong way to help fans meet each other, and they can start as a coffee in one city.

Is there a business case?

There can be. Resler points to the show Sober Powered, where ads were about a third of revenue and its Circle community almost half. That's one example, and it's from a topic where people have strong reasons to support each other. Don't treat it as a forecast.

For brands, the payoff usually looks different. A community of customers or peers can give you guest ideas, honest feedback and warm relationships. It also needs a clear owner on your team, because a neglected community reflects badly on the brand.

A simple first step

This week, write to five listeners and ask them what they'd want from other people who love the show. You'll learn more from those replies than from any platform comparison.

Want to build a stronger relationship with your listeners? Talk to the Poddster team.

Jessica Tamar Young
Author
Jessica Tamar Young
Head of Content Marketing, Poddster

Jess leads marketing and content at Poddster, with 8 years of experience in content creation, digital marketing and podcasting. At Poddster, she's the go-to for industry intelligence, new platform updates and research, usually before anyone else has heard of them.

Podcast industry updates, sent to your inbox.

Get our weekly round-up of the latest developments and trends in podcasting.

You're subscribed. Look out for our next email.
You may already be subscribed. If not, please check your email address and try again.

Start creating with Poddster.

Join 5.1K podcasters, creators, and brands already producing, editing and growing their video content with the world's #1 podcast studio brand.

Select your region

You can change it anytime from the main menu.